Immigration Reform: Being Played For a Fool Again

Date Put forth on May 21, 2007 by XicanoPwr
Category Posted in Elections 2008, Immigration, Immigration Debate, NAFTA, Nativism, News/Noticias, Racism, Xenophobia

America is an idea, a set of beliefs about people and their relationships and the kind of society which holds the best hope of satisfying the needs each of us brings as an individual. The global mobility of human resources between countries is a key driving force of the currently ongoing economic and regional development all over the world. In reality, [tag]immigration[/tag] exerts many positive and important impacts on a country’s economic, cultural and social structure. It will be hard to find any country in the world where immigrants never contribute to the development of a country. However, here in the Good Ole U.S. of A, immigration is being called into question by immigration critics who are compiled to exaggerate how the large influx in immigration has contributed to the increase in unemployment and other serious social problems. Some critics even go so far to argue that this country is losing it’s cultural heritage. And like clockwork, each year, the politicos in DC try to cater to their demands by addressing the problem by trying to create a comprehensive immigration reform bill.

Last week, after having a secret meeting, key senators from both parties along with the White House reached a compromise on a comprehensive [tag]immigration reform[/tag] bill. What is interesting about this bill, is the way this bill is being fast tracked through the Senate and how it is being shoved down our throats regardless of our opinions. The 300 + page text was cut-n-pasted from last year’s failed legislation with some revision done last Saturday by Senate staff. Key sections continue to be changed throughout the Senate’s debate of the bill, this is one reason it is hard to find detailed analysis of the legislation on the Internet, especially on the progressive side of the blogosphere. For those on the right, it is a simple regurgitation of the ole xenophobic rhetoric.

[tag]George Lakoff[/tag] was correct on how we metaphorically describe this nation as a family because the way everything is handled, it feels like this nation is one big dysfunctional family, where the politicos in office are the parents and we – the people – are its children. And like any family, we are being told what to do, regardless if we like it or not. However, it seems the parents are not seeing eye-to-eye on this bill; both parties are very intent in preventing this bill from reaching the president’s desk. Even though the media describes the bill as “comprehensive immigration reform,” the fact is, this bill is anything but “comprehensive.”

The bill has four major provisions which eventually transform the present family-based immigration system into a “Rich man’s immigration system” that would curb future immigration only to those who can afford the high visa cost and those with college degrees, while at the same time creating a new bracero program and adding more border cops to the Southern border. The proposed bill primary focus is ending the so-called “chain migration” by creating a point system where high skill, income, and education levels determine eligibility for immigration are valued more than a person’s family; however, there are some who state this is not true and that the system would reward those who are less educated.

The proposed bill also gives priority to “enforcement” to such measures as doubling the size of the Border Patrol, vastly expanding the military-style barriers along the US-Mexico border, increasing the number and size of detention facilities for undocumented workers, and establishing a new police-state technology for workplace checks the legal status of every worker in the United States.

The proposal would establish a temporary worker program (the old [tag]bracero[/tag] program, just renamed) that would bring in new immigrants to the US while creating a separate program for seasonal migrant workers. Skills and education-level would be weighted over family connections in deciding whether prospective immigrants should get permanent legal status. In other words, the comprehensive immigration reform bill is reverting to the 1917 Immigration bill that forced everybody over sixteen years of age to take a literacy test. Those who were considered ignorant were not allowed to come in. This time around, it is being called a merit system – a system that is being used in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand.

The bill would allow 400,000 temporary workers to enter the country each year on “[tag]Y visas[/tag]” to fill the multitude high skills jobs that Americans can do, but cost too much and would let employers have the option to cut cost and hire immigrants to do those jobs. The visa is renewable; however, it is limited to a total of three two-year-periods, thereby ensuring a truly “temporary” worker program. As immigrants toil under conditions of thinly disguised slavery, they are effectively denied the right to bring family members with them by making them them jump through unreasonable hurdles – such as providing evidence that their spouses and children have private health insurance coverage.

It is interesting to see the how the media and the more hysterical anti-immigrant demagogues claim that this bill is offering “[tag]amnesty[/tag]” to 12 million undocumented immigrants, when the simple fact is, the Senate bill is not an amnesty program. The comprehensive reform bill is simply another smoke and mirrors ploy, in which millions of undocumented immigrants would face various conditions making it difficult “path” to earned citizenship, such as passing background checks, paying fines, and “getting in line.” Under the proposed legislation, in order for the undocumented workers to qualify for this new “path” to citizenship, they would have to apply for a four-year renewable temporary “[tag]Z visa[/tag]”, which would mean they would have to cough up $5,000 in fees and penalties and pay an additional $1,500 processing fee for each person applying for a Z visa. Even though this visa can be renewable indefinitely, the bill does not mention if the $5,000 a one-time penalty or that they would continue coughing up that amount each time they were to renew their visa. Once this is done, the visa holder can then be qualified to convert their visa to permanent residency if the head of household applies within 8 years and RETURNS to their home country to collect the visa at a consulate. However, they must remain there for 6 to 8 months before they can begin their “path” to citizenship. This would also include paying another $4,000 fine along with a $3,500 visa fee. Permanent status would only be granted after the Department of Homeland Security has cleared its backlog of the four million applications by legal immigrants who are waiting for their visas to bring relatives into the country. The process can take about eight or plus years to clear. The “legalization” process abounds with provisions described as “triggers,” that would determine if they can stay or not. It would not be surprising to see hundreds of thousands of immigrants be denied legal status and exposed to immediate deportation.

What’s more, our elected leaders, tried to fast track this bill without having a true dialogue. Clearly, both Republicans and Democrats were catering to both conservative and liberal voters, in hopes of winning their votes in the upcoming 2008 presidential elections rather than the lives and suffering of the immigrants who do not have a vote. If passed, it would have truly demoralized millions of people and their families into feeling like unwelcome guests, this also goes for the non-brown immigrants. The bill would have put everything just slightly out of reach for them. It will make them feel like they are on some treadmill being told pay a little more and all your dreams will be met just over the horizon. What they don’t realize it is just a carrot dangling on a stick just inches out of their reach, and no matter how far they think they have gone, they are still on the same treadmill and the carrot is still there, still just out of reach. The only ones who benefit for this are the corporation with their cheap labor.

If there is a reason causing the large influx of immigration from Mexico into the US, it is NAFTA. For the past 13 years, North American Free Trade Agreement ([tag]NAFTA[/tag]) has provided cover for our imperialistic march for power and profit. Predatory multinational corporations have prospered from their economic conquest as they allied themselves with friendly governments at the expense of ordinary working people who ultimately paid the price. The result – mass and growing poverty, human misery, and ecological destruction great enough to threaten the ability of the planet to sustain life.

The Senate bill could not help but reflect who would benefit from this bill – the business sector. Even though the business sector spoke against the bill, in reality, it was the elite capitalist from major corporate players in agriculture, construction, and other sectors of the economy who drafted the bill. Both parties want to assure businesses have a large exploitable documented temporary worker pool they can use as needed, abuse as they wish, underpay, deny benefits and above all use as a wedge to destroy organized labor and the rights of all working people in the country. We must remain astute that it is our [tag]neoliberal agenda[/tag] that is driving millions of people to abandon their home. They are here to seek a better life, only to find themselves to be exploited in the workplace and terrorized by Homeland Security ICE storm troopers.

We must be aware of the hypocritical nature of wanting to benefit economically from the Mexican migration; but at the same time, create a hostile environment driven by fear against immigrants to control migration flows. It is time for human, civil rights, and other progressive organizations to mount a combined effort to fight back! We can no longer sit back and watch this country be destroyed itself at the expense of society’s most vulnerable while the capitalist continue to get wealthier on the backs of the immigrant people, while they receive nothing in return.

It is, time to end this racist war on immigrants.

Tags Tags: , , , , , , , , | |

8 Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. odd X-rated Immigration Bill « The Mex Files Trackback on May 25th, 2007 at 3:19 am
  2. even looking back and cautiously forward « one step closer… Trackback on May 25th, 2007 at 9:03 am
  3. odd looking back and cautiously forward « one step closer… Trackback on May 25th, 2007 at 9:03 am
  4. even Immigration reform: America's new bracero program « Scholars and Rogues Trackback on May 26th, 2007 at 10:32 am
  5. odd Immigration: Icky Thump « Fitness for the Occasion Trackback on Jun 1st, 2007 at 9:40 am
  6. even » The Immigration Bill is Defeated: Never Underestimate the Power of the People - By ¡Para Justicia y Libertad! Trackback on Jun 8th, 2007 at 2:25 pm
  7. odd » Senate's Second Secret Immigration Bill - By ¡Para Justicia y Libertad! Trackback on Jun 21st, 2007 at 1:07 pm
  8. even The Senate’s secret immigration bill: round two « Scholars and Rogues Trackback on Jun 22nd, 2007 at 5:03 am


You can follow any responses to this entry through the Feed Comments (RSS) feed.

  1. Gravatar Icon Tony Herrera May 21st, 2007 at 11:43 pm

    Aside from the exorbitant fees and the proverbial treadmill that this bill would seemingly places immigrants onto, I fear that the only thin missing, is the part about the unscrupulous labor contractor. Stay tuned!

    I hate being so damned cynical.

  2. Gravatar Icon Sylvia May 23rd, 2007 at 6:19 pm

    I think this post has been the easiest to understand about the comprehensive immigration reform issue. Perhaps the most disconcerting part of the proposed bill is the merit system — designating who deserves to be an American by point value is the cruelest irony in action. How many natural citizens would fail this meritocracy ploy?

    Anyway, thank you for this post and for setting the gears in my brain in motion about how to counteract this rapidly developing racist, sexist, classist and xenophobic myth we’re being spoonfed.

  3. Gravatar Icon XicanoPwr May 24th, 2007 at 8:33 am

    Thanks Sylvia – It was the hardest thing to do because there really isn’t much out there. When you do a search all you get is your typical I hate Mexicans links. Hopefully, this will get out there in time for people to read before the Senate is in session again.

  4. Gravatar Icon Laura May 25th, 2007 at 8:49 am

    Great summary and commentary.

  5. Gravatar Icon Immigration Sep 13th, 2009 at 2:38 am

    Great article – thanks! You can learn more about Canadian Immigration Process, as well as the different histories and more at

  6. Gravatar Icon Immigration Sep 19th, 2009 at 11:16 pm

    Your site is very informative. Thanks for the great content! Our site is very similar and we will plan on sending traffic your way. Our site includes loads of ideas related to Canadian Immigration & tutorials, and more:




Sorry, comments for this entry are closed at this time.